IMPLANTABLE COLLAMER LENS (ICL)
by STAAR SURGICAL COMPANY
The IMPLANTABLE COLLAMER LENS (ICL) by STAAR SURGICAL COMPANY has a safety score of 59 out of 100, placing it in the elevated-risk category. Based on FDA MAUDE data, there have been 29,051 adverse event reports since its introduction in 2015. With an estimated 0 units in use, the incident rate is 0 per 10,000 units. It ranks #54 out of 54 devices in the Ophthalmic category.
Should you be concerned? A safety score of 59/100 warrants careful consideration. With 29,051 adverse event reports, the risk profile is elevated compared to alternatives in the ophthalmic category (which averages 74/100). Ask your doctor about alternative devices with better safety records.
No recalls have been issued for this device — a positive indicator of manufacturing quality and design safety. On the market since 2015, this device has 11 years of real-world data — enough for long-term safety patterns to emerge.
Questions to Ask Your Doctor About the IMPLANTABLE COLLAMER LENS (ICL)
1. “What alternatives exist to the IMPLANTABLE COLLAMER LENS (ICL)?”This device ranks #54 of 54 in the Ophthalmic category. There are 53 devices with better safety scores — ask if any are appropriate for your case.
2. “How many of these have you personally implanted or used?”Surgeon experience with a specific device significantly impacts outcomes. Higher procedure volume correlates with fewer complications.
3. “What are the specific risks for my case?”Overall adverse event rates (0 per 10,000) are averages — your individual risk depends on age, health conditions, and anatomy.
4. “Is there a newer generation of this device available?”The IMPLANTABLE COLLAMER LENS (ICL) has been on the market since 2015 (11 years). Newer versions may have improved safety profiles based on lessons from earlier models.
Adverse Events
Total reports filed with FDA MAUDE
Death Reports
Death reports associated with device
Incident Rate
Per 10,000 units in use
Recalls
No recalls on record
Estimated Units in Use
Based on market data estimates
Category Ranking
In Ophthalmic by safety score
How This Compares
Other Ophthalmic Devices
HEYER-SCHULTE
Unknown
AMO ARRAY MULTIFOCAL LENS
Unknown
ALCON CILCO POSTERIOR CHAMBER LENS
Unknown
HYDROVIEW INTRAOCCULAR LENS
Unknown
Important Context
Adverse event reports reflect reported incidents, not confirmed device failures. Higher numbers may indicate greater device usage, better reporting systems, or increased awareness. This data should be one factor in your research — always consult your physician.